Home | Articles | BookstorePromote Your Music | Music is Your Business | Subscribe
Twitter | Start a Record Label | Radio Promotion | CD Art Design | Music Career Help

Click to email ChrisHow and Why Major Labels
and Independent Labels
Work Together
by Christopher Knab and Bart Day  - Fourfront Media & Music - Posted Mar. 2004

Back to The Academy

Note: The following article is an edited and updated version of the introduction to a chapter on Major Label and Independent Label relations published in the book ‘The Musicians Business and Legal Guide, 3rd Edition” by Prentice-Hall.) 

Major Labels and Independent Labels have a legacy of exposing and discovering all the great music of the last century, but the role these two types of record labels have played over the decades has changed as much as the music itself has changed. Defining the roles these different kind of record labels have in today’s marketplace; as well as understanding the reliance they have on each other is important for anyone who wishes to start their own label, or develop an existing label. The Independent Labels and the Majors realize that to maximize their marketing efforts in an increasingly competitive environment, working together to achieve their mutual goals can be quite beneficial to both parties. 

A ‘Major Label’ is the name given to those labels that currently control over 80% of the records sold every year in this country. These labels have achieved such a high profile over the last couple of decades by operating their own Distribution companies (Sony, BMG (Bertlesmann Music Group) UMG (Universal Music Group), WMG (Warner Music Group), and EMM (EMI Music Marketing)) that sell directly to the many music chain stores, sub-distributors, and mass merchandisers across the country.  

‘Independent Labels’, in the purest sense of the word, are those record labels that distribute their records through what are called Independent Distributors, and are not usually connected to the Major’s distribution systems. But of course it can’t be as simple as all that now can it? 

In today’ popular music environment there are more records being released every year than ever before. The cost of recording and manufacturing records over the last two decades has decreased dramatically, so there is more music being recorded and competing for the attention of a consumer than ever before.

However, when it comes to exposing any of this music, the ownership of, and the relationships with the media that plays and hypes popular music is now controlled for the most part by the Majors and/or their parent companies. 

Without access to the essential media outlets of radio, TV, Internet, magazines and newspapers, an Independent Label might have a difficult time today without the assistance of a Major Label. (There are however more and more Independent labels that have learned how to find a niche, and through unique marketing efforts been able to thrive.) 

Recently, the high cost of Major label mergers and buyouts has put pressure for the Major Labels to return a profit on all the investments they’ve made in controlling the lucrative music marketplace. The time when a Major Label could slowly build an act over several releases has come and gone. Any act signing to a Major Label these days must impress the label with significant CD sales on their initial release, or they run the risk of being dropped by the label. What we have now is a scenario in which the Major Labels and the Independent Labels do rely more on each other than ever before. 

Independent Labels, who find and champion most new trends in popular music, do the Artist Development work for the Majors in many cases. This is not unlike the situation in baseball, whereby some AAA team develops the talents of an outfielder who someday gets promoted to the major leagues. The Independent Label of today can be a label started by an artist/band, or an entrepreneur businessperson who has the talent, finances, and determination to build projects to a point where they fill a particular music niche or realize that they can only grow so far without the power or clout of a Major Label. 

POSSIBLE Reasons for Major Label Affiliation 
Major label affiliation can provide the independent label with a substantial cash infusion, which eliminates the need to continually focus on day-to-day survival issues and allows more effective operation. The major label may also take on such responsibilities as manufacturing and promotion.  

These factors may in turn permit the independent label to expand and/or upgrade its artist roster, or enter a mainstream genre where developmental and promotional costs are much higher than for niche market music. 

Independent labels affiliate with majors to increase their artists’ exposure in commercial media and to expand their distribution networks by increasing their access to major retail record chain stores and rack jobbers. 

Affiliating with a major label can maximize the likelihood of the independent getting paid for records sold. Independent labels, using the traditional independent distribution system, have always faced the risk that an independent distributor will go bankrupt and not pay them. This risk is drastically reduced (if not eliminated) when an independent label distributes through a major label distribution system. These distributors have the financial backing of their multinational parent companies and are able to weather the financial storms of the music industry. They also have more clout than independent distributors to collect from retail and wholesale accounts and are better able to implement strict controls over how many records those retail and wholesale accounts are allowed to buy on credit. 

Issues to Consider 
When an independent label is considering an affiliation with a major label, there are many issues to consider. Here are some specific questions that will help to focus research and analysis:

  • What are the independent label’s present sales volumes and what are they likely to be in the next few years (i.e., with major label affiliation versus without major label affiliation)?
  • Will the major label distribute to the mom-and-pop stores, which formerly carried the independent label?
  • Will the major label be responsive to regional demands and the demands of niche markets?
  • What kind of reputation and support does the independent label have among its fans?
  • Will a major label affiliation jeopardize this?
  • Will the independent label’s core fans be best served by the major label’s distribution system?
There are other issues to consider as well. For example: 
  • Will an affiliation with a major label create an unhealthy pressure on the independent label to sell more records than it can comfortably or realistically sell?
  • What is the present financial status of the independent label and what is its access to additional resources without major label affiliation?
  • Assuming affiliation, what will the cash infusion (if any) be used for?
  • How can the independent label’s existing staff—promotion, marketing and administrative—be best utilized after affiliation?
  • How will the long-term business objectives of the independent label be served by affiliating with a major label?
  • Do the owners of the independent label really want the responsibilities and financial burdens of operating a fully-staffed record company and overseeing the promotion and marketing of records?
  • Are they only interested in the creative process of signing artists and producing records?
  • What is the personal style of the independent label’s owner(s)?
  • Do they place a high value on being able to operate independently?
  • Are they willing to take input and direction from a large corporate entity?
  • What is the major label’s real motivation for entering into the relationship? Is it to use the independent label as an “indie front,” or to take over the label’s strongest artists?
  • Does it view the relationship as a mutually beneficial long-term strategic alliance?
  • What is the corporate style of the major label’s management? Is there sound long-term vision?
  • Is there good personal chemistry between the management of the major label and the independent label?

Types of Deals 
There are numerous types of deals between independent and major labels, the most common of which are as follows: (1) Pressing and distribution (P&D) deals; (2) distribution only deals; (3) fulfillment deals; (4) production deals; (5) joint ventures; (6) equity deals; (7) the licensing of records to major labels; (8) the licensing of records from major labels; and (9) rights buyouts. 

As a practical matter, the type of contract offered by a major label, its specific terms, and the degree of flexibility in the major label’s bargaining position, will all be dictated by the extent to which the independent label has strong artists, a healthy and ever-improving sales record, and the confidence of the major label in the independent’s key personnel.  

For a detailed discussion of the types of deals I have listed above get a copy of the book “The Musicians Business and Legal Guide”, published by Prentice-Hall.


Christopher Knab is an independent music business consultant based in Seattle, Washington. He is available for private consultations on promoting and marketing independent music, and can be reached by email at: chris@chrisknab.net

Chris Knab's new book,
'Music Is Your Business' is available NOW from the Music Biz Academy bookstore.

Visit the
FourFront Media and Music website for more information on the business of music from Christopher Knab.

Bart Day is a Portland-based entertainment attorney in private practice and is also music counsel for Vivendi Universal Games, the computer game division of Universal Studios.

Bart is also the co-author of a chapter (entitled “Contracts and Relationships between Major Labels and Independent Labels”) in
The Musician’s Business and Legal Guide, a book compiled by the Beverly Hills Bar Association and published by Prentice-Hall Publishing (New York).

The reader is cautioned to seek the advice of the reader's own attorney concerning the applicability of the general principles discussed in this column to the reader's own activities.

Contact information for Bart Day:
1435 NW 19th Avenue
Portland, Oregon 97209
Telephone: 503-224-4900


Submit An Article for Consideration!
Would you like to submit an article for publication at MusicBizAcademy.com? If you have music-related expertise you'd like to share with other musicians including career tips, how to's, or general music business-related articles, please feel free to send them our way. We'll be glad to consider them.
Submit your article!


The Four Fronts...
Artist/Product Development

Get Educated...
Master the Music Biz!
Online Courses. Many Programs. Learn Day or Night.

Details Here

Christopher Knab

Music Is Your Business
Christopher Knab and Bartley F. Day's expanded edition of "Music Is Your Business" is filled with more insights into the business side of being a successful musician or band. Included are chapters on both Internet and traditional music marketing methods. The essential legal issues you need to know are explained as are music contract tips, how to license your music, attract distributors, get radio airplay and create a demand for your music. More...

How to Promote Your Music Successfully on the Internet

How to Promote Your Music Successfully on the Internet
Our in-depth guide to music promotion demonstrates how you can combine powerful internet marketing techniques to sell your music merchandise online! Learn what works, what doesn't, and what you shouldn't waste your time and money on.

Our Top 25 Articles
How to Write an Artist Bio
Performance Contracts
Mastering Your Music
How to Copyright Music
21 Songwriting Tips

Tax Tips for Musicians

Sell Your CDs Online

What's a Record Deal About?
Artist/Band Interview Form

Inside Record Labels
Internship Do's & Don'ts
How to Make a Living w/ Music

How to Write a Press Release
Reasons Demos Are Rejected
Facts About Music Licensing

Trademark Your Band Name?
Planning A Radio Campaign
A Legal Checklist
Industry Quotes to Live By
Songwriting Techniques
Guerrilla Marketing Tips
Starting a Music Business
Live Performance
Music Marketing Plan
Can U Afford Distribution?

Lots More Articles...

All Content © 1996-2013
Midnight Rain Productions.
All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy